Are Carnivorous Plants Safe for Cats, Dogs and Kids?
It's a reasonable thing to wonder. A plant that eats animals sounds like something you wouldn't want near your cat.
In reality, the risk usually goes the other way. A bored cat can wreck a sundew very quickly.
Still, if you have pets or young children, you want a real answer. Below is what the toxicity databases say about each type of carnivorous plant, and where they don't say anything at all.
Plant by plant
Venus flytrap
The ASPCA lists the Venus flytrap as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses. Of all the carnivorous plants, this one has the clearest answer. You can browse our Venus flytraps here.
Cobra lily
The cobra lily, also called Darlingtonia or the California pitcher plant, is also listed by the ASPCA as non-toxic to dogs, cats and horses. It's not an easy plant to grow, though, so it's an unusual choice for a busy household.
Tropical pitcher plants
Clemson Extension's fact sheet on tropical pitcher plants, or Nepenthes, lists them as safe for pets. They usually grow in hanging baskets, too, which keeps them out of reach anyway.
Two easy ones to start with:
North American pitcher plants
We couldn't find an ASPCA listing for these plants, which are called Sarracenia. Scientists have found a toxic compound called coniine in the nectar of the yellow pitcher plant. However, we didn't find any reports of pets being poisoned by one.
So they haven't been shown to be dangerous, but they haven't been shown to be safe either. Grow them outdoors, or somewhere a pet that chews plants can't reach them.
Sundews and butterworts
It's the same story here. Neither one is on the ASPCA's list, and we didn't find reliable reports either way. Their sticky leaves can also make a mess of whiskers and paws, so a high shelf is a good idea anyway.
If your pet eats part of any plant and seems unwell, call your vet or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center. Don't wait to see if it gets better.
What about children?
A Venus flytrap is a great plant for kids. A trap can close on a fingertip, but it's much too weak to hurt anyone, and kids love watching it snap shut.
There are two things worth explaining to them first.
The first is that each trap can only close a handful of times before it wears out. Closing the traps over and over just to watch them uses them up.
The second is no hamburger. Meat is too rich and rots inside the trap. To feed a flytrap, use a small live insect, or a dried bloodworm soaked in water. After it closes, gently squeeze the trap for a few seconds so it starts digesting.
Water is the other thing that kids, and plenty of adults, get wrong. These plants need distilled water, rainwater or reverse osmosis water, not tap water. Our water guide explains why.
Setups that work well with pets
- A Nepenthes in a hanging basket near a bright window facing east or west. Clemson lists it as safe for pets, and it's out of reach.
- A flytrap or pitcher plant outdoors on a sunny porch or in a bog planter, where an indoor cat never gets to it.
- Butterworts and sundews on a high, bright shelf, or under a grow light on a bookcase.
Our recommendation for homes with pets
If you have a cat or dog and want one carnivorous plant, start with a Venus flytrap or a Nepenthes 'Miranda'. Those two have an actual "non-toxic" or "pet safe" listing behind them.
For a child who wants more than one plant, the sundew, Sarracenia and flytrap starter pack gives them three different kinds of trap to compare. Just keep it somewhere the pets can't reach.
If you're not sure which plant suits your home, our buying guide walks you through it.
Sources
- ASPCA, Venus flytrap and California pitcher plant
- Clemson HGIC, Tropical pitcher plants (Nepenthes spp.)
- Wikipedia, Sarracenia (coniine in S. flava nectar)
- International Carnivorous Plant Society, Feeding plants
- RHS, Venus flytrap fact sheet