Which Carnivorous Plant Should You Buy? A Grower's Buying Guide

butterwort, buying guide, carnivorous plants, pitcher plant, sundew, venus flytrap -

Which Carnivorous Plant Should You Buy? A Grower's Buying Guide

Most people buy a Venus flytrap first because it's the one they've heard of. Sometimes that's the right call. A lot of the time, though, a different plant would have been much happier where they put it, and they'd still have a plant.

So before you pick by looks, figure out two things: where it's going to live, and what you want out of it. Those two answers narrow things down fast.

Start with where it'll live

A sunny spot outdoors (porch, deck, balcony). This is where the North American bog plants shine. Venus flytraps and Sarracenia pitcher plants want full sun and a cold winter, and outdoors they get both without you doing much. Most Sarracenia are hardy outdoors to zone 7. In colder places, overwinter the pot in an unheated garage, or look for the northern purple pitcher plant, which the ICPS says survives outdoors even in zone 5 and colder.

A bright windowsill indoors. Go with a Mexican butterwort or a Cape sundew. Neither one needs a winter dormancy, and both do fine in normal household air. Cape sundews like more light than a lot of windows give them, so pick your brightest one.

A spot with bright, indirect light and some humidity. That's tropical pitcher plant territory. Easy hybrids like Nepenthes 'Miranda' and Nepenthes 'Lady Luck' hang their pitchers off the leaf tips, never go dormant, and look great in a hanging basket near an east or west window.

Under a grow light. Almost anything works here. Butterworts, sundews and Nepenthes are the easiest because none of them needs a cold winter. Flytraps and Sarracenia grow well under strong lights too, but you'll still need to sort out their winter rest.

Then decide what you want from it

"I want it to eat my fungus gnats." Get a big Mexican butterwort or a Cape sundew. Both have sticky leaves that small flies can't escape. Fair warning: they catch adult gnats, not the larvae in your soil, so you'll still want to deal with the soil itself (BTi and letting the surface dry out do most of that). The butterwort and Cape sundew starter pack covers both bases.

"I want to watch it snap." That's a Venus flytrap and nothing else. An adult flytrap has traps big enough to actually see what's going on. Named cultivars like Red Piranha or the all-red Akai Ryu are mostly about color and trap shape. Care is the same, though the deep red ones need strong light to color up.

"I want something that looks incredible." Tall Sarracenia are hard to beat. A yellow pitcher plant like S. flava 'Red Throat' can grow pitchers 1.5 to 3 feet tall. If you want a showpiece indoors, a Nepenthes in a hanging basket is the move.

"I'm buying for a kid." A flytrap is the obvious pick because kids want to see something happen. A starter pack takes the pressure off, since one plant doing great makes up for one that sulks. The sundew, Sarracenia and flytrap starter pack gives them three completely different traps to compare.

"I already grow these and want something unusual." Look at the cobra lily (Darlingtonia), named Sarracenia like 'Persian Rug' or the giant Okefenokee form of S. minor, and the less common sundews like the woolly sundew. Be honest with yourself about the cobra lily, though. The ICPS says its roots need to stay under 80°F, and most people find it hard.

The quick version

Your situation Good first pick
Sunny outdoor spot, zone 7 or warmer Venus flytrap or almost any Sarracenia
Sunny outdoor spot, colder winters Any Sarracenia or flytrap, wintered in an unheated garage
Bright windowsill Mexican butterwort, Cape sundew
Bright indirect light, decent humidity Nepenthes hybrid ('Miranda', 'Lady Luck')
Grow light shelf Butterworts, sundews, Nepenthes
Fungus gnats Big Mexican butterwort, Cape sundew

Questions to ask before you check out

Is it going to arrive dormant? If you're buying a flytrap or Sarracenia between about November and February, possibly. Dormant plants look half-dead and are perfectly healthy. It's normal, and our winter dormancy guide shows what to expect. Butterworts, Cape sundews and Nepenthes don't go dormant, so they're the safer winter buys if you want something that looks good on arrival.

Bare-root or potted? Bare-root plants ship without soil, wrapped in moss, and you pot them up within a day or two. Potted plants arrive ready to go. Bare-root is fine if you've got pots, mix and pure water ready before the box shows up.

How big will it get? A flytrap stays small, about 6 to 8 inches across. Butterworts stay compact too. Sarracenia range from about 9 inches (purple pitcher plants) to 3 feet or more (yellow pitcher plants and the Okefenokee S. minor). Nepenthes are vines and typically reach 2 to 3 feet indoors.

Is it safe around pets? The ASPCA lists the Venus flytrap and the cobra lily as non-toxic to cats and dogs, and Clemson Extension lists Nepenthes as pet safe. Sundews, butterworts and Sarracenia aren't on the ASPCA's list either way, so keep those out of reach of a chewer.

What else do I need? Pure water (distilled, rain or RO), a mix with no fertilizer in it, and a pot with drainage. If you're not sure about your water, a TDS meter settles it.

Still can't decide?

Grab a mixed set. The 5-plant assortment lets you find out which ones like your conditions, and you'll know exactly what to buy more of next season. You can also browse everything we carry in the carnivorous plants collection.

Sources