Butterwort Care: How to Grow Mexican Pinguicula Indoors
If you want a carnivorous plant that's happy on a windowsill, a Mexican butterwort is a great choice. Butterworts, known by the scientific name Pinguicula, need a bright window, a gritty soil mix and pure water. In return, they catch gnats on their sticky leaves all summer and grow pretty flowers that look a lot like violets.
The one thing that confuses people is winter. In the colder months, the plant changes so much that it can look like a completely different plant. This guide explains what to expect.
How a butterwort catches insects
A butterwort grows as a flat rosette of soft, slightly fleshy leaves. The leaves feel greasy, a bit like butter. In good light, the surface glistens.
That shine comes from two kinds of tiny glands on the leaves. One kind makes a sticky substance that traps small insects when they land. The other kind sits flat on the leaf and releases digestive enzymes once an insect is caught. The plant then absorbs the nutrients straight through the leaf. Charles Darwin wrote about this process in his 1875 book Insectivorous Plants.
The butterworts sold as houseplants are Mexican species and hybrids. Mexico has more kinds of butterwort than anywhere else in the world. There were 55 known species at last count, after botanists described a new one from the state of Oaxaca in 2025.
Many of these plants grow in mountains with a long dry season, and ten of them grow on gypsum soils. Keep the dry season in mind, because it explains most of what they need from you.
Light
Put your butterwort in your brightest window, or under a grow light. East-facing and south-facing windows both work.
Good light keeps the plant compact, and it often turns the leaves pink or red. In weak light, the leaves stretch out, turn pale and lose their stickiness.
They don't need intense sun, though. Specialist growers lightly shade their greenhouses in summer. If a hot south window starts to bleach the leaves, move the pot back a little.
If your butterwort lives under a grow light all the time, there's one thing to know. According to the International Carnivorous Plant Society, butterworts switch between their summer and winter leaves in response to slowly changing day length. So in fall, shorten the light's timer a little at a time. In spring, lengthen it again. Don't run the same hours all year.
Water
Like most carnivorous plants, butterworts need pure water. Use distilled water, rainwater or reverse osmosis water. A cheap TDS meter can tell you whether your water is clean enough. Our carnivorous plant water guide explains this in more detail.
How much you water depends on the season.
From spring through fall, many people keep the pot in a shallow tray with up to about 2 cm (¾ inch) of water. It's fine if the tray dries out for a few days now and then.
In winter, water much less. Let the tray stay dry for about a week between waterings. Too much water in winter is one of the easiest ways to lose a butterwort.
Soil
Butterworts like a gritty mix that drains quickly. The International Carnivorous Plant Society suggests this recipe for houseplants:
- 1 part plain sphagnum peat moss, with no fertilizer
- 1 part coarse sand
- 1 part perlite, or pumice instead of perlite
Then mix in about a tablespoon of dolomitic lime for every cup of soil. This surprises people, because most carnivorous plants like acidic soil. Mexican butterworts are different. They prefer soil that's slightly alkaline. Some experienced growers skip the peat completely and use a mix made only of minerals.
Use a plastic or glazed pot. Unglazed terracotta is porous, so it lets the soil dry out faster.
Butterwort roots are short, so a 3 to 4 inch pot is big enough for one plant. You'll only need to repot about every five years. Repot sooner if you see a white crust of minerals on the soil.
Avoid regular potting soil, mixes that say they "feed for months," and cactus mixes with added fertilizer.
What happens in winter
Every fall, most Mexican butterworts stop growing their large, sticky leaves. Instead, they form a tight, small rosette of thick leaves that aren't sticky at all. It looks more like a small succulent than a carnivorous plant.
This is completely normal. It's how the plant gets through the dry winter in Mexico.
During this time, water much less, keep the plant in bright light, and keep it a little cooler if you can. Then leave it alone. When the days get longer in spring, it will start growing sticky leaves again on its own.
Specialist growers point out one risk. The winter rosette sometimes sits partly buried in the soil, and watering heavily at that point can cause it to rot. Water around the plant, not into the center.
Growing new plants from a leaf
Butterworts are one of the easiest plants to propagate. The International Carnivorous Plant Society says winter, when the plant is in its succulent stage, is the best time to try.
- Gently wiggle a healthy outer leaf sideways until it pops off at the base. You want the whole leaf, including the pale part where it was attached.
- Lay it flat on damp soil or damp sphagnum moss. Don't bury it.
- Keep it in bright light and high humidity. A clear lid with a small gap for air works well.
- Wait. A tiny new plant often appears at the base of the leaf within a few weeks.
- Once it has a few leaves of its own, move it to its own pot.
Do butterworts get rid of fungus gnats?
They do catch fungus gnats. Growers often say a couple of large plants can catch a lot of them. But they only catch the adults. The larvae live in the soil, and they can even attack the butterwort itself. We explain how to deal with the larvae in Do Butterworts Get Rid of Fungus Gnats?
Common problems
The leaves aren't sticky anymore. This usually means the plant needs more light. It can also happen when the plant switches to its winter leaves. Either way, the next set of summer leaves should be sticky.
The leaves are stretched and pale. This also points to too little light. Move the plant to a brighter window, or move the grow light closer.
The center of the plant is rotting. This almost always means too much water, usually in winter. Let it dry out, and water around the plant from now on.
There's a white crust on the soil. Minerals are building up from water that isn't pure enough. Repot the plant in fresh soil and switch to pure water.
The leaves are small and thick in winter. That's normal. It's the winter form.
Please don't treat butterworts with fungicide, and that includes cinnamon. The International Carnivorous Plant Society specifically warns against it for butterworts.
Choosing a butterwort
Almost any Mexican species or hybrid makes a good first plant, and hybrids tend to be especially tough. After that, it depends on what you want.
For a first plant, or for catching gnats:
- Pinguicula hybrids: sold in 4-inch pots, so you get a good-sized plant right away. Bigger plants catch more gnats.
- 'Hanka': another easy one.
For color:
- P. agnata 'Red Leaf': selected for red leaves.
- P. moranensis var. roseii: selected for pink leaves.
Good light brings out the color in both.
For collectors:
If you'd like a sundew as well, the butterwort and Cape sundew starter pack includes one of each.
Questions to ask before buying
How big will it be when it arrives? It depends on the listing. Some butterworts ship as small rosettes about an inch across. Others come in 4-inch pots, and a few ship without soil. If size matters to you, check the product title before you order.
How big will it get? Butterworts stay small. Most will fit on a narrow windowsill.
Will it look dead in winter? No, but it will look different. It shrinks into a small, tight rosette and stops being sticky until spring.
Does it need a terrarium? No. Normal household humidity is fine, as long as the air moves a little.
Is it safe around pets? Butterworts don't appear on the ASPCA's list of toxic or non-toxic plants, so we can't say either way. To be safe, keep it where a pet can't chew on it.
Products that help
You can see every type we carry in our butterwort collection.
For the soil mix, we have Viagrow perlite and pumice. The HM Digital TDS-3 will check your water. If your windows don't get much light, a SunBlaster LED strip can help.
Sources
- International Carnivorous Plant Society, Mexican Pinguicula growing guide
- Eric Partrat, Growing Mexican Pinguicula, pinguicula.org
- Y. Heslop-Harrison, "Scanning electron microscopy of fresh leaves of Pinguicula," Science 167 (1970): 172–174
- López-Pérez, Zamudio, Rodríguez & Munguía-Lino, "A new species and species richness distribution of the gypsophyte butterworts (Pinguicula) in Mexico," Botanical Sciences 103(3), 2025